Heterogeneous populations develop herd immunity quicker


Comparison between potential courses of an epidemic wave in a populations of various heterogeneity. The curves share the same initial rapid growth, characterized by R0=2,5. The more heterogeneous a population is, the quicker the epidemic becomes self-limiting. The curves show the course of infection numbers in an epidemic without containment measures. (R0: Reproduction rate of the epidemic, meaning the number of new infections that an infected person causes on average). Credit: Neipel et al. 2020

In rapidly spreading epidemics such as the current coronavirus pandemic, it is usually expected that a majority of the population will be infected before herd immunity is achieved and the epidemic abates. The estimate of when the threshold for this is reached is usually based on models that assume all individuals in a population are identical. Researchers at the Max Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems in Dresden have used a new model to demonstrate that herd immunity can be achieved at a lower threshold if some individuals are more easily infected than others.

Most epidemics abate before the majority of the population becomes infected. What exactly determines this turning point, and the extent of the epidemic, is not yet well understood. Many epidemic models are based on the assumption that individuals in a population are essentially identical. However, in an actual population, every person is different. For example, some people are less likely to become infected through contact with an infected individual, perhaps due to a more effective immune system, or better hygiene.

A team led by Frank Jülicher from the Max Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems has been investigating the influence of this heterogeneity on the spread of an epidemic. When individuals differ in their susceptibility to an infection, it is primarily the most susceptible who become infected first. This leads to a rapid increase in infection numbers at the beginning of an epidemic. However, this highly susceptible portion of the population soon becomes immune or dies. Therefore, in the uninfected population, the average susceptibility to the virus decreases. This slows the infection rate of the epidemic, and thus the threshold for herd immunity can be lower than previously assumed. A heterogeneous population can thus achieve herd immunity even when only a minority of people are immune. In contrast, in a homogeneous population, herd immunity can only be achieved once a majority is immune.

Different scenarios

According to the Dresden researchers’ model, different scenarios can yield what appears to be the same epidemic course. Specifically, two epidemics, which have different levels of heterogeneities and effectiveness of mitigation measures, can have the same reported time course of infection. In a homogeneous population, immunity only plays a significant role in impacting infection rates when a considerable fraction of the population has been immunized. An early decline in infection rates could therefore only be explained by other factors such as containment measures. In contrast, for a highly heterogeneous population, significant reductions in infections can occur when even a small fraction of the population has been immunized.

An early decline in infection rates is not necessarily the result of containment measures alone, but could also be attributed to the fact that a population is approaching the heterogeneous population herd immunity. An evaluation of the effectiveness of epidemic containment measures must therefore consider the heterogeneity of a population.


Follow the latest news on the coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak


More information:
Jonas Neipel et al. Power-law population heterogeneity governs epidemic waves, PLOS ONE (2020). DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0239678

Provided by
Max Planck Society


Citation:
Heterogeneous populations develop herd immunity quicker (2020, October 30)
retrieved 30 October 2020
from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-10-heterogeneous-populations-herd-immunity-quicker.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.



Health care informatics news

Source – medicalxpress.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *